8 Facebook Competitive Analysis Tools, An Epic Guide

by Lisa Peyton on Dec 06, 2011

A Facebook business page has become an essential component for most digital marketing campaigns.

But what do you know about your competitors on Facebook?

Perhaps you have scanned their page, taken notice of how many fans they have or even ‘liked’ their page so you could be updated on their status.

The information available on your competitors is astounding and the following tools can help make that information actionable.These platforms will save hours in producing competitive analysis reports.

Getting Started

These tools DO NOT require you to be the admin of the page but DO however assume you KNOW who your competitors are on Facebook.

If you want help discovering the top performing Facebook pages in your industry, scroll down to #8 for my  ‘Honorable Mention’  where I discuss the Momentus Community Health Score. Their free tool will show how your page ranks among other competitors in your category or industry.

There’s a chance  I’ve overlooked a tool or two, so please be sure to comment and let me know.

Facebook Page Competitive Analysis ‘Cheat Sheet’

Facebook page competitive analysis tool 'cheat sheet'

Top Facebook Page Competitive Analysis Tools

1. Socialbakers.com

Cost: Starts at $50 per month
Historical Data: Last 30 days upon sign-up
Number of pages monitored: 100 or more
Strength: Head to head comparison of 2 Facebook pages

Historical Data

As soon as you sign-up you have access to the last 30 days of data for all Facebook pages. The platform allows you to view all charts based upon the last 7 days, the last month or a custom date range.

Leaderboard

The summary comparison stats for each page is displayed via the Engagement Analytics leaderboard. The platform allows you to customize this chart to include or exclude the following data for each Facebook page:

  • Picture
  • Fan Growth
  • Country Reach
  • Response Rate
  • Page Posts
  • Name
  • Page Score
  • Home Tab
  • Avg. Response Time
  • Most Favourite Type
  • Fans
  • Avg. ER
  • Number of Tabs
  • Wall Posts
  • Interactions
Head to Head

Apart from getting an overview of all the pages you are monitoring, you can also compare 2 pages, side by side. Socialbakers has developed a unique Fan page score based upon the following stats: Fan growth rate, quality of content, engagement rate and quality of your posting strategy. They also list these Key Performance Indicators side by side, so at-a-glance you can determine how your page stacks up to your competitors.

Socialbakers.com 'People Talking About This' graph for Facebook pages

The amount of data in this head to head comparison is astounding and most of the charts in this section or exportable to either a CSV file or an image. They include a graph that charts the ‘People Talking About’ metric for each day of the month, so you can determine if Facebook users are talking more about your brand or your competitor. This chart would help to determine the effectiveness of off-line campaigns in creating on-line buzz or mentions.

Benchmarking

Another extremely impressive feature of this tool is the comprehensive ‘Benchmarking’ chart that lets you see the KPI’s for all pages side by side on a bar graph.

Sadly, these charts don’t appear to be exportable. Particularly interesting is the ‘Trends’ tab where you can compare 2 sets of data for all brand pages and have the result displayed in a bar graph, line graph that spans your date range or interactive bubble graph.

So for example, you can chart the country reach (percent of total population engaged with the page) of each page against the fan growth rate and have an interactive chart that tells you which brand has a larger share of voice nationwide. The tool also can produce data on global reach.

2) All Facebook

Cost: Free for up to 3 pages, paid plans start at $69 per month
Historical Data: Up to one year upon sign-up
Number of pages monitored: Up to 75
Strength: Great price point for amazing amounts of exportable data

All Facebook houses an impressive amount of data for a very reasonable price point. the interface is user-friendly and offers up a ‘Help’ sidebar the defines the data parameters and offers helpful hints. Upon sign-up for the free account, I had access to a full-year’s worth of historical data.

Allfacebook.com Help menu within their Facebook page comparison tool

The All Facebook dashboard is customizable and allows you to add a variety of different widgets, so you can quickly view the most valuable data sets. Widgets include charts reviewing the following data.

Fans:

  • Fan Total
  • Interaction Rate
  • Fan Growth Rate
  • Fan Distribution
  • Fan Change – Chart with absolute change of the fancount of Facebook Pages for a specific time interval.

Interactions:

  • Own Posts – Chart with the number of own posts of Facebook pages for a specific time interval.
  • User Posts
  • Total Posts
  • Likes, Comments, Interactions Average per Post
  • Interaction Rate – Chart with the average number of interactions per own post normalized per fan of Facebook Pages for a specific time interval.
  • Response Times
  • Interaction rate by Post Type
  • People Talking About This Chart

Location:

  • Checkins Total – Chart with the development of the checkins of Facebook Pages for a specific time interval.
  • Checkins Change
Quick Analysis

The ‘Quick Analysis’ feature allows you to quickly compare a specific data-set for all of your competitors pages. For example, if you wanted to learn what types of content your competitors had been posting of the last year, you could do that with just a few clicks. The example below compares the types of content posted on three of the major social media brand Facebook pages over the course of 2011.

Allfacebook.com quick analyisis feature allows you to quickly view graphs for any data set

Reports

Most charts are exportable to several formats including a PNG, PDF, JPEG or even a SVG vector image. If you want to spring for the $399 per month Business package, the platform can export reports to a CSV file as well.

3) Zuum Social

Cost: Starts at $25 monthly for 5 pages, $50 for 10
Historical Data: Access to data dating back to Jan 2010 within 24hrs of sign-up
Number of pages monitored: Up to 10
Strength: Presenting actionable insights such as best day to post and engagement rate for post types.

Zuum Social creates reports comparing up to 10 Facebook pages. The dashboard lists some actionable stats for each page including the Engagement Rate, Best Engagement Day, Best Media Type and Best Engagement Hour. Data can be displayed daily, weekly, monthly or quarterly. The platform also will provide the most engaging admin and fan posts for all compared pages.

Engaging Brand Conversations

A unique feature of this platform are the ‘Conversation Themes’ outlined in an exportable chart. The tool will aggregate keywords used on at least 2 pages and bucket posts that use the key term.

It then displays which ‘theme’ is being discussed on each page and how engaging that theme or conversation is based upon fan interactions. The example below calculates popular ‘themes’ for the 2012 presidential candidates during Thanksgiving week.

Industry Reports

All of the charts and graphs are exportable in various formats including JPG, PDF, PNG, vector and CSV file. Once you become a client you not only have access to your custom reports but any of the industry sample reports that Zuum social offers. Sample reports include information on the 2012 presidential candidates, airlines, fashion retailers, footwear, snack foods, hospitals, and automotive brands.

Zuum Tool Guides

Zuum has also put together an impressive guide to working with their tool and how to derive insights from the data collected. (http://www.zuumsocial.com/how/our-facebook-marketing-tool-tutorials) Topics include Report Settings, Media Type Analysis Charts, Quantity to Quality Ratio Chart, Conversation Topics Charts and more.

4) SimplyMeasured.com

Cost: Starts at $500 per month
Historical Data: Min of 3 months and up to 1 year at sign-up
Number of pages monitored: Up to 5 at no cost, paid plans based upon number of fans
Strength: Well-designed reports in both Excel and PowerPoint

Simply Measured offers comparison reports on Facebook and Twitter. They have a free Facebook competitive analysis report, comparing up to 5 Facebook pages.

They don’t charge a fee for this report but do require you to send out a tweet promoting their services. The free report offers up data for the last 2 weeks and includes charts comparing the following stats:

  • Total engagement displayed via fan interactions and based upon the percentage of fans engaged
  • Total Fans
  • Fan Page Engagement Comparison Over Time – Fan interactions for each page plotted daily
  • Fan Page Engagement Details Comparison – Bar graph depicting the number of fan posts, fan comments and fan likes for each brand
  • Average Response Per Post – Outlines the average number of clicks, comments and likes per post for each brand pages. (This chart had some formatting issues with the online version, but was clearly outlined in the exported version.)

This free report is exportable to an Excel spreadsheet and a PowerPoint slide deck. You have the option to use an existing PowerPoint theme so you can quickly customize the report with your own logo.

Their professional or paid services are more comprehensive and allow you to run reports comparing up to 10 Facebook fan pages. The tool is report driven which means there aren’t any online dashboards comparing data but all the data is bundled into Excel or PowerPoint documents that can be viewed online.

The paid version of the report includes 2 additional charts, New Page Likes Comparison Over Time and Top Posts by Comments. Their paid plans start at $500 which allow you to monitor up to 250,000 fans/followers on an ongoing basis.

5) TwitSprout.com

Cost: $88 monthly for up to 50 Facebook pages
Historical Data: 1 week prior to the date of sign-up and then the data aggregates hourly
Number of pages monitored: Up to 50
Strength: Data on content type

Twitspout is launching a Facebook Page comparison tool early next year and they were nice enough to give me a sneak peak. The tool is currently available for clients who who register for their white label solution.

The platform will allow users to compare metrics for up to 50 competitors Facebook Pages, including Total Fans, Engagement per Post, Posts per Day, Likes per Post, Fans Fans recruited per Day, Comments per Post and Response Time.

The leaderboard shown below will sort your competitors pages based upon any of the available metrics you choose. Clicking on the Facebook Page name will take you to an exportable details page that includes page stats such as growth rate, engagement rate and average response time.

Engagement Levels by Post Type

This feature isn’t unique to TwitSprout but the way they have chosen to display the data does make it a snap to gain valuable insight. TwitSprout co-founder, Dan Holowack, explains the goal is to have the inner circle match the outer circle. As shown below, Social Media Examiner could boost engagement by posting more photos and less links.

Twitter Included

TwitSprout accounts include up to fifty competitive pages or accounts and 25 authorized accounts across both Twitter and Facebook with plans to extend to LinkedIn.

6) Blitzmetrics

Cost: Free
Historical Data: Up to 1 year
Number of pages monitored: Up to 3
Strength: Formulates an ‘Earned Media Value’ for any Facebook page you administer

Blitzmetrics.com offers Facebook dashboards and was developed by Dennis Yu from BlitzLocal. The tool is currently free with additional features available for premium clients. The free dashboard allows you to compare your Facebook page with up to 3 of your competitors.

Earned Media Value

This is the first tool I’ve reviewed that actually derives a dollar amount from the engagement resulting from the Facebook page. In order to get this value, you DO have to be the admin of the page and this data isn’t available for your competitors. According to Yu, the “earned media value is defaulted to a $5 CPM calculation, but can be configured for premium clients to have values for a fan, like, comment, share, and so forth.” This calculation should be very compelling to marketers tasked with proving the value of a Facebook page.

Competitors

The tool will monitor 3 competitors and provide either a graph or table view. Reported stats include:

  • Fans
  • Posts
  • Likes
  • Admin Posts
  • Comments
  • Interactions
  • Engagement % – interactions divided by fan base
  • Market Share – share of fans for each brand
  • Share of Voice – share of interactions for each brand

7) Wildfire

Cost: Free
Historical Data: Up to one year
Number of pages monitored: Up to 10
Strength: Great customer service

Wildfire offers a free Facebook comparison tool that simply charts the # of page fans over time for up to four Facebook pages. The data includes the actual number of page likes as well as a growth rate percentage. They also report on a page ‘rank’ based upon the number of fans and unique visits to the page compared to ALL Facebook pages.

This tool really doesn’t present any actionable data and is weak sauce compared to the other platforms reviewed in this article. I was thankful that Wildfire had a ‘chat’ feature so I could get answers to my questions immediately. Kira was very helpful and answered all my questions promptly.

8) Momentus Community Health Score – Honorable Mention

 

Momentus offers a Facebook page grader that quickly ranks any Facebook page against competitors in the same category. The tool presents ‘vital statistics’ which include overall fans, admin posts per day, likes/comments, community posts per day, community responses and then calculates an overall health score. They also present a list of the Facebook Pages that rank HIGHER than your brand page, based upon your page category. This allows you to quickly scan the list for any potential direct competitors that might be outperforming you on Facebook.

Size Doesn’t Matter

Now you know the types of data you can collect on competitors, it’s time to think about which data sets are actionable for your own campaign.

What can these stats from your Facebook competition teach you about engaging your Facebook community? Remember we’ve all moved past simply measuring the size of the community or number of fans. It’s all about the ‘motion of the ocean’.

Don’t despair if your competitors have recruited more fans, these tools will help you take  a closer look.

Social Fresh Tips Newsletter

Our top social marketing tips, tricks, and tactics dropped in your inbox every week!

Post Author

Lisa is a leader in the field of digital marketing. Based in Portland, OR, she serves as executive editor at TMMPDX.COM and teaches digital strategy at Portland State University. Her services include social media coaching, content strategy and digital...

  • http://twitter.com/eernoult eernoult

    Great article Lisa! I knew some of them, but not all. Good inspiration for us ;-)

  • http://twitter.com/wildfireapp Wildfire

    Thanks for the shoutout, Lisa! Wanted to point out that if you log in (which is to your free account), you can track and save up to 10 pages. Return to them as much as you want, share the growth with your colleagues, the graphs will update in near real-time with all the competitors you set, free. It really is like compete.com for Facebook and Twitter. Cheers!

  • kalpana ganesan

    I like this post. i just find a company informatics outsourcing from Google search. They are market research service company providing Business Research services Worldwide with affordable price.

  • Lisa Peyton

    Thanks for the update. I have added that info to the section about Wildfire.

  • Lisa Peyton

    Thanks so much for the feedback, it’s much appreciated!

  • http://twitter.com/brookmiller Brook Miller

    Lisa,  

    Great article, really appreciate the depth.  Our technology team is here in PDX and you’ve got an open invitation to stop by if you’d like to learn more about our company and product.

    We just launched our new tool into the mix on Monday, we’re moving beyond the metrics to help understand emotions.  I hope you’ll check it out and add to the list. 

    http://www.fathomresearch.com

    Thanks,Brook

  • Anonymous

    where is the Truth? evry client wanna see the ROI, esp. via money…. i can’t stand thier love of money oriented approach…lol

  • http://twitter.com/wdavidturner W David Turner

    Lisa,  awesome breakdown of everyone.  We’d love for you to check out PageLever as well if you’d like.  We’re on the private data side of things, not the public like most of the folks listed here.  

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/4AYFRTA7K5UNAV4F6SDP2UOX34 Noel

    Lisa,
    Wildfire works really well. It
    seems that webtrends are doing some cool stuff with facebook but I
    haven’t had a chance to try any of their products. SocialDon another analytics tool helping you to give you statistic of your company, giving you statistic of competitors Fanpage and they don’t charge you for anything.

  • Raymond Bond

    Came across one more site “TrackMyBrand.com”

  • Guest

    I am just testing the Builder PRO from http://www.socialbakers.com. Looks pretty good, but the price is not fantastic. But free Builder PRO module can suit to the most of Facebook fan pages

  • http://twitter.com/HappymantH Happyman

    Great Tips. I like it.

  • http://twitter.com/Likealyzer Likealyzer

    We’ve just released our brand new to tool to analyze and gets ideas on how to improve your Facebook page – likealyzer.com. Would love to get your thoughts on this!

  • http://www.smartedesigners.com/ Smart eDesigners

    Pls. let me know how can I Thank you…. This is great. Thanks you so much for summarized…

  • http://www.tumarketingpolitico.com/ Will de la Vega

    Hi Lisa, do you maybe know what happened to the Momentus page grader? The link doesn´t seem to work anymore and the momentus site doesn´t provide any info either. It would be great if you could share an update on this. Thanks for your excellent article.

  • lisapeyton

    Hi Will, Thanks for the feedback. I’m also unable to
    source a new link for the Momentus Pagegrader. It’s a shame as it was a great resource. Anyone have suggestions on another tool that can fit the bill?

  • http://www.preppyrunner.com Theodora

    Is it possible to update this post? It still ranks high, so I’m finding it searching for competitive analysis, and many of these services have significantly changed over the past two years.